NRO's Corner Blog
March 10, 2011
by Paul Marshall
The violence against Copts in Egypt reported yesterday on NRO by Nina Shea is now being covered more widely (see here, here). There is still much that has not yet been reported in the West, but many in the Egyptian press are doing a good job.
The violence in the last two days has been concentrated on the east side of Cairo in the famous Christian neighborhood of Mokatam, more popularly known as "Garbage City." Most of the garbage collection in Cairo is done privately, by Christians, the zabaleen, who pick it up in trucks and carts, take it back to where they live, and sort through it for anything valuable, which they sell. They live amongst the garbage. This Coptic community, numbering perhaps in the tens of thousands, used to live closer in, but Nasser forcibly removed them to what was then a remote area outside the city.
They have suffered many indignities. In what was first said to be a swine-flu precaution and later a general health measure, the Egyptian government announced in April 2009 a mass cull of pigs in the country. Since Islam holds pigs to be unclean, nearly all the pigs were owned by Copts, many in Garbage City. Hundreds of Coptic pig farmers in Mokatam clashed with police as the latter sought to take the animals for slaughter: Many Christians, already quite literally dirt poor, lost their livelihoods. Egypt is the only country to have engaged in such a killing of pigs; the World Health Organization has said it is unnecessary to combat the A(H1N1) flu strain.
Mokatam is also the site of one of the most unusual churches in the Middle East: the Church of St. Samaan (Simon) the Tanner, popularly known as the 'cave church.' Despite its huge Coptic population, Garbage City had no church at first, and the government stymied attempts to get permission to build one. The Copts then deepened the caves in the hill overshadowing their warren of streets and began to meet and worship there. Now the largest of the caves will hold over 10,000 people, and regularly does.
Much of the deadly violence took place not during demonstrations but later, by gangs roving through Mokatam. In what was more a pogrom than a 'sectarian clash,' Muslim mobs, including some armed with guns, roamed Garbage City at night, as late as 2 a.m. Homes were looted and set on fire using combustible propane tanks, and garbage recycling plants and trucks were destroyed.
Al Masry Al Youm quotes one resident: "Despite there being sectarian tension before, especially after the Two Saints [Church] bombing in Alexandra [at New Year], there has never been such an organized attack on the Copts here before."
One knowledgeable long-time resident writes: "Although over 130 people were injured, most through gun shots and some very seriously, no ambulances or fire engines arrived at the Village until early the next morning. Our two, rather primitive hospitals up there did there best to treat the wounded and many people are now in the city hospitals. So far, 1ten have died, nine of them young Christians and one a Muslim who lives at the Village and was defending his home there." She adds that it was "obvious that this was a well-organized and deliberate attack on Christians in general and Garbage People in particular."
So far, the promise of a new Egypt is not materializing for many Copts. If anything, the rate of attacks on them has increased in the last month. Veteran reporter Arne Fjeldstad, in daily contact with people in the area, notes: "Particularly serious is the fact that the army people shot against the zabaleens. This may be a social/class issue — garbage collectors are 'unclean,' used to have pigs, etc. — but it definitely is a warning against Copts. The whole area is poor and there is a lot of anger (against society, the powers, as well as 'the others') that has been built up over the years, and which had been mostly suppressed under Mubarak."
Paul Marshall is a Senior Fellow with Hudson Institute's Center for Religious Freedom.
Home | Learn About Hudson | Hudson Scholars | Find an Expert | Support Hudson | Contact Information | Site Map
Policy Centers | Research Areas | Publications & Op-Eds | Hudson Bookstore
Hudson Institute, Inc. 1015 15th Street, N.W. 6th Floor Washington, DC 20005
Phone: 202.974.2400 Fax: 202.974.2410 Email the Webmaster
© Copyright 2013 Hudson Institute, Inc.