Skip to main content

The Real Problem Transcends Policy

Kenneth R. Weinstein

The unspeakable tragedy at Virginia Tech is not a public policy problem but something that greatly transcends it. Monday’s carnage might possibly have been limited through a number of policy options: greater controls on the sale of semi-automatic weapons; better mental health laws that can help force obviously ill adults like the murderer — whose own writings foreshadowed the attacks — into counseling and therapy, even against their will; and improved methods of instantaneous emergency communication that in Blacksburg, as on 9/11, could well have saved many.

The real problem is deeper. We live in a vibrant civil society, in which individuals take their responsibilities to each other seriously. We also live in a schizophrenic age: a church-going era, but one of electronic fantasy, of individualized entertainment that encourages atomization from our immediate social environment.

When, at times, our culture glorifies gratuitous and consequence-free violence through horror movies, Internet sites, and video and computer games, the impact on marginal personalities, like the murderer, can be deadly. That the mix of fantasy, narcissism, social frustration, mental illness and access to semi-automatic weapons does not lead to even more frequent acts of horrific violence is itself astonishing.

In short, the problem goes well beyond Washington — to New York and Hollywood, but also to every home in America. Parents have a responsibility to be watchful of their own children, to be honest about their children’s pastimes and their mental states.

Related Articles

Marijuana Legalization Undermines Obama Administration’s Health Goals

John P. Walters & David W. Murray

The Obama administration, driven by the notion that America’s prisons are unjustly filled with first-time marijuana offenders, has condoned marijuan...

Continue Reading

The Coming Showdown Between Philanthrolocalism and Effective Altruism

William A. Schambra

A showdown is coming for those of us who argue that charitable giving should attend first to our own community. We face the challenge of a new movemen...

Continue Reading

He Chose Wrong

Lee Smith

While the encomia from world leaders and cultural figures continue to pour in after the death of Gabriel García Márquez at the age of 87 last month,...

Continue Reading