Skip to main content

The Worst Reason Not to Aid Syria

Ann Marlowe

“We don’t know who the opposition is!”

Fainéant pundits and politicians are once again reviving this trope, now as an excuse for removing America entirely from any influence in the direction of Syria’s revolution. In the spring of 2011, it was the standard plaint about the Libyan rebels. In both cases, this demand for knowledge shows a lack of understanding about how Muslim societies under dictatorship have evolved.

This “knowing” is often meant both in the sense of personal acquaintance and of factual knowledge that can be verified online.  (I am leaving aside what, if anything more, American intelligence agencies know but are keeping to themselves.) And in truth, more than a year later, while we know a lot more about the top members of the National Transition Council and some of the candidates for the newly elected National Assembly, we still don’t have the kind of information in digital form that accumulates around even, say, a candidate for a congressional seat in the US. Some of the NTC members have never said much to the press, either Arabic- or English-language. But Libya has not become a failed state or a breeding ground for extremists, and in fact it rejected the Muslim Brotherhood in the July 7th elections for the National Assembly. Somehow, Libya has survived despite American pundits’ lack of full information.

The demand for facts deserves some discussion. Generally, it is hard to get beyond basic biographical information for people living under Arab dictatorships. Only their friends or schoolmates will know much, for a number of reasons.

Click Here to View Complete Article.

Related Articles

Democratic and Republican Elites Are Using Trump to Whitewash 16 Years of Foreign-Policy Disasters

Lee Smith

Successive two-term administrations made a mess of the Middle East. Who will clean up?...

Continue Reading

New Appointments Give Clues on Trump's European Policy

Benjamin Haddad

Wess Mitchell nominated for Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs...

Continue Reading

Bush, Obama & Trump: The Evolution of the United States’ Counter-Terrorism Policy Post 9/11

Douglas J. Feith

On September 12th, Douglas Feith participated in an event held by the Herzliya Interdisciplinary Center's International Institute for Counter-Terroris...

Watch Now