Skip to main content
Don't Entrust Jerusalem to the Muslims or the Jews (or the French)
A group of British soldiers in the court of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in 1917 in Jerusalem. (Getty Images)
(Getty Images)

Don't Entrust Jerusalem to the Muslims or the Jews (or the French)

Douglas J. Feith

In his essay in Mosaic on diplomacy, law, and Jerusalem, the estimable Michel Gurfinkiel asks, “What is international law?” and comments, “It’s easy enough to doubt, if not to mock, the idea that there is such a thing.” It sure is. The last century of U.S. policy on Jerusalem is a tale of cynicism and sanctimony that makes one wonder whether U.S. officials ever take international law seriously.

The Holy City commanded little international attention in the 700 or so years after Muslims defeated the Christian Crusaders. That changed, however, in December 1917, when British forces captured Jerusalem from the Ottomans in World War I. The city and its holy places became a diplomatic issue. British officials spoke passionately of their duty to keep the city and its holy sites under Christian—and specifically British—control.

Handing it all back to the Muslims was out of the question for the men who led the British Empire. Even those who were pro-Zionist, such as Prime Minister David Lloyd George, couldn’t quite imagine Jews in charge of the city, with authority over the Church of the Holy Sepulcher and the Garden of Gethsemane. Nor was Lloyd George receptive to claims of interest in Jerusalem by the French, whom he scorned as “atheistic” or, in any event, Roman Catholic.

For the 30 years after World War I, Britain administered Palestine. Its officials established Jerusalem, naturally, as the seat of government there. Mostly Protestants, they quarreled with Vatican representatives and Eastern Orthodox Church clerics over various municipal matters, but one thing they all agreed on was that the city could not be entrusted to Muslims or Jews.

That was the origin of the idea that, when Palestine is eventually partitioned between the Jews and the Arabs, Jerusalem should be internationalized.

Read the full article in Mosaic Magazine.

Related Articles

Macron’s Islamophobic Undercurrent

Bruno Maçães

French foreign policy appears driven by a fear Europe risks being subsumed by Islam....

Continue Reading

Trump Is Hosting Turkey's Erdogan to Show off His Dealmaking. but He's Going to Get Played.

Blaise Misztal

With Erdogan adept at speaking Trump’s language and the U.S. having no clear strategy for Turkey, the only deal the president's going to get is a raw ...

Continue Reading

President Trump Argues Tariffs Are Hurting the Chinese Economy, Not the U.S.

Michael Pillsbury

In an interview with Shannon Bream on Fox News, Michael Pillsbury discusses the U.S.-China trade talks. ...

Watch Now