Skip to main content
The FTC Joins Huawei on a Misguided Troll Hunt
The FTC's Apex Building

The FTC Joins Huawei on a Misguided Troll Hunt

Adam Mossoff

Qualcomm, the American company whose technology turned cellphones into smartphones, can’t seem to get any respect lately. The chip designer was hauled in for trial this month in a suit the Federal Trade Commission filed in the final days of the Obama administration. The FTC claims Qualcomm violates antitrust laws by overcharging phone makers for using its patented technology like 4G in smartphones. The lawsuit threatens to weaken the patents that have secured the key innovations of the modern tech age.

The FTC’s star witness in the first days of trial was Huawei, the Chinese telecommunications giant the Trump administration has called out for stealing intellectual property from American companies. Last month, at America’s request, Canada arrested a Huawei executive, escalating the trade war resulting from the U.S. challenge to China’s intellectual-property theft. Apparently, the FTC missed the irony of having Huawei testify about how a leading U.S. tech innovator is allegedly violating antitrust laws in licensing its patents to Huawei.

The FTC is blinded by a panic about “patent trolls” that has run rampant in Washington for the past decade. Like the fabled troll under the bridge, the story is that patent owners hold up companies from manufacturing new products or services by demanding a toll—a license to use their patents. The moral of the story is that these patent owners are somehow killing innovation by demanding extortionate royalties from companies that must use their technology in making and selling products like smartphones.

Read the full article in the Wall Street Journal

Related Articles

The Realignment Ep. 39: Michael Shellenberger's Alternatives to the Green New Deal

Marshall Kosloff & Saagar Enjeti

Michael Shellenberger, environmentalist activist, founder and president of Environmental Progress, joins The Realignment to make the pro-nuclear, anti...

Listen Now

Transcript: The Threat Posed by the Chinese Government and the Chinese Communist Party to the Economic and National Security of the United States

Walter Russell Mead & Christopher Wray

Following is the full transcript of the July 7th, 2020 Hudson online livestream event titled China’s Attempt to Influence U.S. Institutions: A Convers...

Continue Reading

The Multitier Battle Against Chinese 5G Dominance

Thomas J. Duesterberg

China’s ascent to global market share leadership in advanced commercial telecommunications has featured many tactics: subsidization of domestic produc...

Continue Reading