Skip to main content
Qatar Airways jet over Greece, April, 2018 (Nicolas Economou/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
(Photo credit: Nicolas Economou/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Subsidies and Unfair Competition in Global Commercial Aviation: How to Respond

Thomas J. Duesterberg

View PDF

Executive Summary

Commercial air passenger service is a mixed business with privately owned companies competing against state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and partially state-owned firms throughout much of the world. Because World Trade Organization (WTO) rules and those of other trade agreements do not apply to international air passenger service, a system of bilateral “Open Skies” agreements has developed in order to open markets, reduce government interference in international aviation, and facilitate efficient resolution of disputes over rates, landing rights, and general fair practices for commercial aviation. In recent years, heavily subsidized SOEs in the Persian Gulf states Qatar and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) have posed a major challenge to the maintenance of a stable Open Skies regime, however. Using tens of billions of dollars in government-provided capital not available to their overseas competitors, these SOEs have taken significant market share from established airlines in the United States, Europe, Australia, and India, for example. And subsidized SOE air carriers in China—which has no open skies agreements with the world’s major industrialized nations except Australia—are beginning to raise many of the same concerns.

Earlier in 2018, the United States and the two Gulf sheikdoms concluded separate bilateral agreements intended to begin addressing this problem. Both accords mandated greater transparency in accounting by Qatari and UAE-owned air carriers so that unfair, market-distorting government subsidies would be more visible, and each agreement also included concessions from the sheikdoms about a related irritant: the proliferation of third-country stopover destinations on otherwise direct Gulf-carrier routes to and from the United States.

These accords are too new for any confident prediction to be made about how effective they will ultimately be in restoring open and fair competition to international commercial aviation. The United States—and its allies in Europe and Asia, many of whose established airlines have also been hurt by subsidized SOE competition from the Persian Gulf—should remain highly vigilant until relevant data can be collected and analyzed. Qatar Airlines recently purchased the small Italian carrier Meridiana, restocked its aging fleet, rebranded the company “Air Italy,” and began opening new international routes with third-country stopovers—which suggests an intention to evade the spirit of the U.S.- Qatari agreement. In the future, if the results prove disappointing, expanded use of the WTO or other trade agreements may be worth considering as a further tool to help address the problem of SOEs in general, not just those affecting the airline industry. In the meantime, however, the U.S. and its allies should vigorously pursue the guarantees of financial transparency and fair and equal opportunity to compete accorded to their domestic air carriers by the open skies system—and give cautious but serious consideration to the pursuit of additional open skies agreements with China, which currently operates outside the system’s framework of rules.

View PDF

Related Articles

The Final Stretch of the U.S.-China Trade Talks

Michael Pillsbury

In an interview with Stuart Varney on Fox Business, Mike Pillsbury discusses the final stretch of the U.S.-China trade talks and the potential of an u...

Watch Now

Europe Gets Its Competition With China All Wrong

Bruno Maçães

Protecting the liberal order won’t be enough. The EU will also have to challenge China for influence around the world....

Continue Reading

Why the US is Partnering with Brazil in Space Race Against China

Sean Kelly

The U.S.-Brazil agreement is a good first step towards promoting deeper space cooperation and countering China’s ambitions in the region....

Continue Reading