04
November 2014
Past Event
The Historical Split Between Charity and Philanthropy

The Historical Split Between Charity and Philanthropy

Past Event
Hudson Institute
November 04, 2014
04
November 2014
Past Event

1015 15th Street, N.W., 6th Floor
Washington, DC 20005

Speakers:
David C. Hammack

Hiram C. Haydn Professor of History at Case Western Reserve University

Benjamin Soskis

Fellow, Center for Nonprofit Management, Philanthropy, and Policy, George Mason University

Patty Stonesifer

President and Chief Executive of Martha’s Table

Scott Walter

Executive Vice President of the Capital Research Center

As many of you know, we are about to close the doors on the Bradley Center for Philanthropy and Civil Society, after 12 years of operation and 148 panel discussions on all aspects of philanthropy and the nonprofit sector, approaching them from a rich variety of disciplines and points of view. Nothing could be more appropriate for our final panel than to turn our attention to the proudest claim of the modern American foundation: namely, that it practices philanthropy – it solves problems at their source – as opposed to charity, which merely puts band-aids on problems.

We commissioned the first thoroughgoing historical monograph on this topic from Benjamin Soskis, a Fellow at George Mason's Center for Nonprofit Management, Philanthropy and Policy. The Chronicle of Philanthropy just ran an op-ed he wrote, drawing from the monograph. To discuss this major addition to the scholarship on philanthropy and civil society, we assembled a distinguished panel, including Case Western Reserve Professor David Hammack, Patty Stonesifer, formerly of the Gates Foundation, and Scott Walter of the Capital Research Center. Hudson Institute Senior Fellow William Schambra moderated.

Required Reading:
"Both More and No More: The Historical Split Between Charity and Philanthropy":http://hudson.org/research/10723-both-more-and-no-more-the-historical-s… by Benjamin Soskis

"Today’s Problems Call for Reviving Charity—and Eliminating the Need for It":http://philanthropy.com/article/Today-s-Problems-Call-for/149427/ by Benjamin Soskis

Related Events
22
May 2026
Virtual Event | Online Only
The Western Hemisphere’s Energy Moment
Featured Speakers:
Daniel Batlle
Francisco Monaldi
Getty Images
22
May 2026
Virtual Event | Online Only
The Western Hemisphere’s Energy Moment

Join Hudson Institute as Adjunct Fellow Daniel Batlle interviews Francisco Monaldi, director of the Latin American Energy Program at Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy and one of the foremost authorities on energy and political economy in the region, for a wide-ranging conversation on Latin America's energy future and what it means for the hemisphere and for US interests.

Getty Images
Featured Speakers:
Daniel Batlle
Francisco Monaldi
18
June 2026
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
Deterring Russia and China: Securing America’s Nuclear Future
Featured Speakers:
Rebeccah L. Heinrichs
Brandon Williams
Getty Images
18
June 2026
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
Deterring Russia and China: Securing America’s Nuclear Future

Join Senior Fellow and Keystone Defense Initiative Director Dr. Rebeccah Heinrichs and Administrator of the National Nuclear Security Administration Brandon Williams for a discussion on the administration's priorities in strengthening the US nuclear enterprise.

Getty Images
Featured Speakers:
Rebeccah L. Heinrichs
Brandon Williams
21
May 2026
Past Event
Georgia at a Geopolitical Crossroads: Iranian Influence and Strategic Competition
Featured Speakers:
Luke Coffey
Giorgi Kandelaki
John P. Walters
Congressman Joe Wilson
Ian McGinnity
Moderator:
Matthew Boyse
Tbilisi residents protest after the Georgian Dream government announced a suspension of negotiations on EU candidate status until 2028, as police detain demonstrators during a crackdown in the capital on November 28, 2025. (Photo by Sebastien Canaud/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
21
May 2026
Past Event
Georgia at a Geopolitical Crossroads: Iranian Influence and Strategic Competition
Tbilisi residents protest after the Georgian Dream government announced a suspension of negotiations on EU candidate status until 2028, as police detain demonstrators during a crackdown in the capital on November 28, 2025. (Photo by Sebastien Canaud/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
Featured Speakers:
Luke Coffey
Giorgi Kandelaki
John P. Walters
Congressman Joe Wilson
Ian McGinnity
Moderator:
Matthew Boyse
12
May 2026
Past Event
China’s Persecution: Assault on All Faiths
Featured Speakers:
Sam Brownback
Hon. Frank Wolf
Grace Jin Drexel
Peter Xu
Pastor Pan Yongguang
Pastor Corey Jackson
Wang Chunyan
Mihrigul Tursun
Frances Hui
Enes Freedom
Arjia Rinpoche
Moderators:
Nina Shea
Michael Arkush
This picture taken on July 19, 2023 shows a view of a watchtower of an alleged detention facility in Artux in Kizilsu Prefecture in China's northwestern Xinjiang region. Since 2017, more than a million Uyghurs and other Muslims have been swept into internment camps where human rights abuses are commonplace, researchers, campaigners and members of the diaspora say. Beijing says the facilities were voluntary centres for teaching vocational skills, closed years ago after their inhabitants "graduated" into stab
12
May 2026
Past Event
China’s Persecution: Assault on All Faiths

To address these concerns, former senator Sam Brownback, who served as ambassador at large for international religious freedom in the first Trump administration, will join Senior Fellow Nina Shea to propose new policies for the US government and actions for the American public. 

This picture taken on July 19, 2023 shows a view of a watchtower of an alleged detention facility in Artux in Kizilsu Prefecture in China's northwestern Xinjiang region. Since 2017, more than a million Uyghurs and other Muslims have been swept into internment camps where human rights abuses are commonplace, researchers, campaigners and members of the diaspora say. Beijing says the facilities were voluntary centres for teaching vocational skills, closed years ago after their inhabitants "graduated" into stab
Featured Speakers:
Sam Brownback
Hon. Frank Wolf
Grace Jin Drexel
Peter Xu
Pastor Pan Yongguang
Pastor Corey Jackson
Wang Chunyan
Mihrigul Tursun
Frances Hui
Enes Freedom
Arjia Rinpoche
Moderators:
Nina Shea
Michael Arkush