Skip to main content
More Political Interference Will Hurt, Not Help, the US Military
Soldiers assigned to the 82nd Airborne provide security during an evacuation at Hamid Karzai International Airport, Kabul, Afghanistan, on August 21, 2021. (Marine Corps photo by Sgt. Isaiah Campbell)
(Marine Corps photo by Sgt. Isaiah Campbell)

More Political Interference Will Hurt, Not Help, the US Military

Nadia Schadlow

For years, US policy-makers criticized the communist systems of Russia and China for placing political commissars into the ranks of their militaries. This criticism was justified: These commissars were, in essence, enforcers. They revealed fundamental weaknesses because their existence suggested that Soviet and Chinese leaders did not have confidence in their commanders, and valued ideological conformity over military competence. Unfortunately, several developments in the Department of Defense offer disturbing hints of an American “commissar mentality.”

In late August, the Defense Department published a Civilian Harm Mitigation and Action plan. The plan reminds us that in war, the “protection of civilians is a strategic priority and moral imperative.” To ensure that military leaders don’t forget this, it establishes a committee focused on mitigating civilian harm, a new “center of excellence,” and “civilian harm assessment cells” that will be deployed with US troops. Implicit in this plan is a mistrust of officers’ ability to embody existing and fundamental tenets of their jobs, such as verifying firepower is applied to minimize risk to civilians.

Read the full article in the National Review.

Related Articles

Let's Get to the End of This War

Rebeccah L. Heinrichs

Rebeccah Heinrichs appears on Fox Business to discuss paths to peace in Ukraine and developments in the Iran nuclear deal. ...

Watch Now

What Putin's Threats Really Mean

David Asher

David Asher appears on NewsNation to discuss what recent Ukraine war news signifies about Putin. ...

Watch Now

Tackling Inflation Requires Energy Clarity

Brigham McCown

Today’s economic and security headwinds have extended into the energy sector, where prices have outpaced inflation while production remains below pr...

Continue Reading