Skip to main content
How Thanksgiving Went from a Day of Prayer to a Day of Feasting
Normal Rockwell's Freedom from Want, Oil on Canvas, 1943 (Public Domain)

How Thanksgiving Went from a Day of Prayer to a Day of Feasting

Melanie Kirkpatrick

If you could travel back in time to 1621, tap a Pilgrim on the shoulder, and ask him to define “Thanksgiving Day,” his answer might surprise you. For the Pilgrims, a “day of thanksgiving” was not marked by feasting, family, and fellowship — the happy hallmarks of the holiday we now celebrate. It was a different matter altogether. A “thanksgiving day” was set aside for prayer and worship.

The Pilgrims brought with them from England the religious custom of marking days of thanksgiving. Days of thanksgiving were called in response to specific beneficences such as a successful harvest, propitious weather, or a military victory. From the Pilgrims’ perspective, their First Thanksgiving in the New World didn’t take place until 1623, two years after they and the Wampanoag Indians sat down together at the now-famous feast. The occasion was a rainfall that saved their harvest — and their lives. If the harvest had failed, famine was sure to follow and the settlement of Plymouth might not have survived.

All the New England colonies followed the custom of designating days of public thanksgiving. At some point in the 1600s, the colonies began to designate annual thanksgiving days, usually in the autumn, around the time of the harvest. These celebrations were deemed “general” thanksgivings for ordinary, everyday blessings. They were usually called by civil, not religious, authorities.

In 1639, Connecticut was the first to make Thanksgiving an annual event. It is impossible to know precisely when the feasting and family aspects of Thanksgiving Day began to overtake the religious ones, but they had caught on by the the end of the 17th century. Churches accommodated the custom of a feast by eliminating the afternoon service. Soon Thanksgiving dinner was nearly as important as morning prayer.

Related Articles

American Conservative Nationalism is Here to Stay

John Fonte

Colin Dueck, Age of Iron: On Conservative Nationalism (Oxford University Press, 2019). Colin Dueck has written a marvelous book explaining the past,...

Continue Reading

The Realignment Ep. 28: Ross Douthat, The Decadent Society

Saagar Enjeti & Marshall Kosloff

Ross Douthat, conservative New York Times columnist and author of __The Decadent Society: How We Became the Victims of Our Own Success__, joins The Re...

Watch Now

The Realignment Ep. 27: Jane Coaston, Covering the Right's Realignment

Saagar Enjeti & Marshall Kosloff

Jane Coaston, Vox senior politics reporter and co-host of The Weeds podcast, joins The Realignment to discuss the state of the conservative movement....

Listen Now